×
What's new

How many pianos do you really have?

67. I use 2.
This seems a common theme in this thread: having dozens but actually using a few. The search for the perfect piano.

I have probably 30 and use only a handful, namely:

- The VSL concert D
- Fracture Sound piano’s, except Midnight Grand
- UVI Augmented Piano - basic patch, love the sound of that Playel.
 
One thing I like about these threads is that I'm reminded of some great pianos I have that I forget about! The UVI Austrian Grand is one of them (along with many of the others in Keysuite). I'm quite fond of just about any piano using the UVI platform, including Acousticsamples and (obviously) VI-Labs. The UVI first-party pianos might not be sampled as deeply, but they're still really nice to play, so responsive and immediate.
 
- I want a clean Yamaha U3 that takes me back 35 years when I used to learn classical on Yamaha uprights: Found it.
Can I ask what virtual upright piano instrument you chose? When I compare it to the real upright piano I have at home, I can't find anything that sounds as good. Apparently listening through headphones versus listening to a real piano also plays a role.
 
My number one go-to for playing pleasure is Pianoteq 8. Just a joy to play!

I also love Simple Sam Steinway, Piano in Blue...but I have way more piano VSTs than one can play in a lifetime...and yet I buy, I buy!
 
VI Labs Modern U. …
Best Yamaha U3 VI. Great playability!

… Don't expect it to substitute your real upright. …
+1.
There is no piano VI that can replace a real piano.

… No sample library or midi controller will you give that magical tactile feedback. …
I use a Yamaha Avantgrand N3 as a midi keyboard because of the key action and the TRS (The Tactile Response System recreates the sensation of piano body vibration). I bought it new long time ago and it was very expensive, but I haven't regretted it.
 
Don't expect it to substitute your real upright. No sample library or midi controller will you give that magical tactile feedback.
Agreed, but I have to say that there are some controller/digital piano’s that at least offer enough of a piano-like action to be able to play more nuanced than say your avarage $300 midi controller. I have a Kawai MP11SE which I use as my main controller and I needed to store for a while due to a renovation at home and it was that time that I really noticed how comfortable I had become with the keyaction. I didn’t enjoy the action of the controller I used as a temporal replacement one bit and not only for piano. No emotional connection at all with the controller keyboard action.
 
Piano-like action is there. It just all gets lost when there is no tactile feedback. Baffles me why digital pianos and controller manufacturers haven't invented something in the same analogy of having an XBOX controller vibrating and reacting to gameplay. Not saying it's the same thing, that's why i said "analogy".
It’s a nice idea, but it would probably just feel fake and you’ll end up paying for a feature you’d rather switch off than use.
 
Piano-like action is there. It just all gets lost when there is no tactile feedback. Baffles me why digital pianos and controller manufacturers haven't invented something in the same analogy of having an XBOX controller vibrating and reacting to gameplay. Not saying it's the same thing, that's why i said "analogy".
As mentioned in my previous post, the Yamaha TRS (Tactile Response System) does just that. You can feel the vibrations in the keyboard and in the pedal. You can clearly hear what you are playing, even without sound, through the vibration of the body. The only problem is the extremely high price for the pianos that have TRS. The most expensive are the Avantgrand models. I like TRS and use it all the time.
 
Last edited:
If any of you is still feeling some kind of FOMO for new sounds after listing all these huge lists I have the Impact Everything Bundle for sale atm.

Feel free to check it out and dm me!

 
Back
Top Bottom