During the last weekend I finally found a small studio in my city, which has probably every library on this planet. They let me in for the weekend(as they don't work during weekends) and I finally got my hands on MSB and MSS(and SF's Abby Road, but that's different story...).
The brass library is amazing. The sound is convincing, clear, stable, controllable and strong, but in the same time very neutral. I had plenty of doubts before due to all the comments, but all of them disappeared in a few hours of playing with this library. I just can't understand how anyone can dislike it. I understand that we all have different preferences, but this library is objectively good - almost everything is there, the sound is solid, the control is on point, recordings/patches are agile(from full ensemble, to individual player).
I suppose people just didn't pay enough attention to auto divisi stuff and some other features that have to be set for different situations(and the fact that we have this kind of control is great, nothing to complain about).
The only thing I would add to this library is an equivalent of "Monster Brass" patches from CineBrass. I hate the childish tone of CB(no offence to anyone, I understand that it is a good library, it's just a matter of personal taste), and it includes those patches. But the idea of this FFFFFFFFFFFFF dynamic is cool and often useful. While MBS can sound loud and strong, this kind of dynamics is very special and can change the character of MBS even more if they add it as a dynamic layer(just imagine the level of dramatism we would be able to acheave with it
).
I also like how natural this library sounds with all kinds of algo reverbs. Ig it's due to that sonic neutrality. Speaking of neutrality - the sound itself is also very agile and responsive: it doesn't matter if you need darker or brighter tone, just use some good clean eq(I used Equilibrium) and it'll sound just like it was recorded this way - a very rare quality tbh.
Long story short, I can go on and on why this library is so great, but my main point is that it does sound strong and sound good. I think this library didn't deserve to be bashed the way it was.
Sometimes it's truly amazing to see how absolutely terrible libraries, which have nothing but interesting recordings/sonic character, while being packed inside of some terrible sampler, with God awful layout, are getting blindly praised, but when something truly great and very well thought through appears, they suddenly open their "Meh" box.