Menu
What's new
By:
Filters

Transcribed: Danny Elfman - Black Beauty

Land of Missing Parts

Land of Missing Parts

Grumpy Monkey
Here's my midi mockup of "Main Titles" from Black Beauty.
Music composed by Danny Elfman.



Transcribed by ear from the soundtrack.


I picked up Embertone's Joshua Bell Violin and Shire Whistle and wanted to do a mockup to put them through their paces. JB Violin doesn't have the kind of molto vibrato that I'd really need to match the recording but I did my best.

Comments and criticisms are appreciated, particularly any mixing, balancing, and orchestration thoughts you might have. If anyone has actual sheets for this, please let me know. I'd love to see what I got wrong.

Thanks for listening. :)

Joshua Bell Violin, Shire Whistle, Cinematic Studio Strings, Caspian Brass, Adventure Brass, Berlin Woodwinds (Legacy), Chocolate Audio Harp.
Click to read more...
 
Last edited:
Wow, I'm impressed! Well done, what a lot of work! I went back and forth a bit, of course there are little differences here and there but nothing that really changes anything. Your mix sounds somewhat compressed compared to the original, but compositionally I think you nailed it. I bet you learned a lot. I don't have the patience for transcription even though I know the time spent would be worth it.
 
Bill the Lesser said:
I bet you learned a lot. I don't have the patience for transcription even though I know the time spent would be worth it.
Click to expand...
Thanks Bill. I still have much to learn, but the exercise did get me thinking about how to make better use of the double bass, and how to dial in more subtle degrees of dynamic change. I started out with more extreme dynamics and little by little had to keep backing everything off.

Another thing I noticed (and I should stress that this is just guesswork) is that when the brass comes in to fill the lower midrange, the strings don't stay and get louder--which would probably sound muddy--but they instead move to a higher range.

Most of what I learned just comes down to feeling though since the song is, compositionally, simpler than I thought at the outset.

whiskers said:
The more I hear it, the kids I think I need to pick up CSS.

Great job buddy
Click to expand...
Thanks Whiskers, I'm surprised you don't already have it. Out of curiosity, what do you use for your workhorse strings?
 
Land of Missing Parts said:
Here's my midi mockup of "Main Titles" from Black Beauty.
Music composed by Danny Elfman.



Transcribed by ear from the soundtrack.


I picked up Embertone's Joshua Bell Violin and Shire Whistle and wanted to do a mockup to put them through their paces. JB Violin doesn't have the kind of molto vibrato that I'd really need to match the recording but I did my best.

Comments and criticisms are appreciated, particularly any mixing, balancing, and orchestration thoughts you might have. If anyone has actual sheets for this, please let me know. I'd love to see what I got wrong.

Thanks for listening. :)

Joshua Bell Violin, Shire Whistle, Cinematic Studio Strings, Caspian Brass, Adventure Brass, Berlin Woodwinds (Legacy), Chocolate Audio Harp.
Click to expand...


WOW!!! Great work on this! One of my favorite Elfman Scores. You made great use of those instruments. I can't offer much in terms of critique, but you have a new soundcloud follower and look forward to more.
 
Great work ! I love this score and it was a pleasure listening to your mockup.

My only complain would be that sometimes I feel the solo violin and whistle share too much of the same MIDI data, rhythmically speaking. Especially at 0:20, where it sounds a bit static compared to the original.

Other than that, bravo ! :)
 
Nailed it!

It is noticeable that you didn't emulate the original solo instruments, but one should ask if that's really the goal since they are simply not the same.

Really loved it, chapeau!

Cheers,

Nipduif

Edit: you got a new follower
 
whitewasteland said:
Great work ! I love this score and it was a pleasure listening to your mockup.
Click to expand...
Thank you whitewasteland, I took inspiration from your excellent mockups so it means a lot.
Nesciochamp said:
It is noticeable that you didn't emulate the original solo instruments, but one should ask if that's really the goal since they are simply not the same.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I like JB Violin but I don't think it can really match this player, or at least I wasn't able to figure out a way. Maybe I'll check out Emotional Violin and Chris Hein and see if they have options to get a little more expressivo.
OleJoergensen said:
How do you do....? :)
Click to expand...
I'd be happy to share what I know, though I'm not sure specifically what you're asking about. I map the tempo, then listen to a part--say the whistle--and match it as best I can with an instrument I have, then just play along as best as I can. I start with the most obvious parts and work through those until eventually my own version sounds like it's got the essentials. But it will inevitably feel like it's still missing some bits, and for that I just kind of guess. I think that's pretty much it, I wasn't terribly technical about it and haven't actually figured out the chords or anything, although I think Elfman tends to be more triadic, at least in this phase of his career.
 
Last edited:
Im sorry, Ive should have been more specific.
I was thinking about your excellent Audio quality.
Which processor do you use and how...?
 
OleJoergensen said:
Im sorry, Ive should have been more specific.
I was thinking about your excellent Audio quality.
Which processor do you use and how...?
Click to expand...
Ah, for processing effects I use Fabfilter Pro-Q 3 for EQ, EAReverb for reverb and spacialization (didn't need a lot here). And a bit of Logic's stock VCA compression on the JB Violin.

On my master bus I just slapped on Softube's Tape and Ozone 8 Essentials and dialed up presets.

The reason I like Pro-Q 3 and EAReverb is that they give good visual tools to see what's going on when my ears might not actually be able to tell. And they are intuitive to use.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom