Stormzy should replace Mozart in UK music classrooms, study says

Discussion in 'OFF-TOPICS - General Musings' started by KallumS, May 22, 2019.

  1. Parsifal666

    Parsifal666 I don't even own a DAW, I'm just a troll.

    3,839
    3,544
    Sep 7, 2015
    E. YeeHaw, Indiana
    If they're going to make a substitute for Wolfie they could at least opt for Beethoven or Mahler. Or Jerry Goldsmith ;)
     
    toomanynotes likes this.
  2. James H

    James H 01001000 01101001

    253
    397
    Dec 20, 2018
    UK
    I heard this on Classic FM this morning, so you can imagine their feeling.

    I mentioned classical music at work, it was met with groans and "here he is, dusty old instrument farty pants"
    I left it an hour... played Game of Thrones, the HZ "Time" on the laptop. Not one moan.

    Schools need to change their approach, not our musical geniuses.
     
    toomanynotes and Parsifal666 like this.
  3. Stanoli

    Stanoli Member

    65
    106
    Aug 21, 2018
    Years ago I bought the Mozart Complete Edition.
    The music is on 170 CDs, which he composed within 30 years.
    Unbelievable polyphonic music he wrote everything with his own hands, Operas, Piano concertos, Symphonies, you name it.

    For the same amount of music it took Bach (153 CDs) 50 years.

    And who the fuck is Stormzy???
     
    toomanynotes and Gaffable like this.
  4. Parsifal666

    Parsifal666 I don't even own a DAW, I'm just a troll.

    3,839
    3,544
    Sep 7, 2015
    E. YeeHaw, Indiana
    It's not the amount of music...lol. In some ways Bach was the greater composer, he was certainly less tied to pre-existent compositional templates. His music was hugely influential on Herr Mozart, particularly on the latter composer's later works.
     
  5. Stanoli

    Stanoli Member

    65
    106
    Aug 21, 2018
    ...see thread title...

    I was more referring to the difference of musical potency between Mozart and contemporary Popartists.

    I hear more Haydn in Mozart than Bach and I think that his staggering amount of created music also implicates importance.

    But I understand, to discuss it this way can be a bit overwhelming.
     
  6. MartinH.

    MartinH. Senior Member

    769
    672
    Jun 16, 2018
    I had a mandatory music course in school for a couple of years and I absolutely hated it! Only class where I ever got an F in a test too I think. I opted out as soon as I could. I only gained an interest in making music when I came into contact with metal genres.

    You'll never have a class that is homogenous enough to interest everyone in the same genre. But I'm 100% in favor of replacing Mozart and Beethoven in those classes with Holst and Williams and showing how the planets and Star Wars connect, and doing all the theory in context of actual composing examples instead of in a vacuum. The theory stuff we covered back then actually went further in part than what I know today, it's just that I understood almost nothing of it back then and it all only clicked once I was making music myself. Today with most theory things that I learn I have an experience of "so that's what that was that I didn't understand back then". Something like guitar pro or fruity loops would have engaged me 100 times more with music and theory than what was covered at my school...
     
    paularthur likes this.
  7. Akarin

    Akarin pragsound.com

    462
    457
    Jan 14, 2018
    Switzerland
  8. LowweeK

    LowweeK Loïc D

    296
    284
    Oct 12, 2015
    Paris, France
    They tried this in France 20 years ago by introducing pop & early hip hop.
    Some classes had budget synths to replace the good old recorder.

    Well, the musical level has not increased much.

    Now they’re back to classical with a bit of pop music too.
    Whatever the music, most scholars are just not motivated.
     
    ptram, KallumS and Gaffable like this.
  9. NoamL

    NoamL Winter <3

    2,437
    4,986
    Jul 6, 2015
    Los Angeles
    You got your head on straight! :2thumbs:

    Hahahaha! I used to do this with John Williams pieces ... I used Audacity to slow down his fast string runs and harp glissandos and try to figure out what scales he was using.
     
  10. NoamL

    NoamL Winter <3

    2,437
    4,986
    Jul 6, 2015
    Los Angeles
    People in this thread: "Rap is just talking with a beat. Rhythm & noise without pitch content isn't music"

    Steve Reich:

    Screen Shot 2019-05-22 at 1.30.52 PM.png

     
    tav.one, kenose, chocobitz825 and 2 others like this.
  11. jbuhler

    jbuhler Senior Member

    1,634
    2,309
    Jun 19, 2016
    US
    You know where kids still routinely learn to play instruments? In communities with strong (American) football traditions. Part of that tradition is having a marching band. Tail waving the dog, perhaps, but traditional music instruction is still valued in those places. I don’t blame the video games or those playing them. If I’m going to assign blame, it would be a world that doesn’t want to invest in or reward musical training. (And, no, that training doesn’t have to be classical training.)
     
    Parsifal666 likes this.
  12. Stanoli

    Stanoli Member

    65
    106
    Aug 21, 2018
    Flamenco without guitars isn`t music, even if it is from Steve Reich.:elephant:
     
  13. chimuelo

    chimuelo Star Of Stage & Screen

    10,988
    2,082
    May 14, 2007
    Between 120-150bpm
    Interesting point but China and the USA lead in the amount of classical teachers, with Japan in third.
    Oddly enough the comments in relation to why is because of the discipline and coordination. Second of course was traditional.

    For me it was just normal to study music, martial arts and sports from Kindergarten forward.

    Comprehension, coordination, appreciation and chops up the ying yang.
    And I help write rap freestyle and hip hop with my son and his merry gang of rappers.

    You get one set of ears and one life.
    Enjoy the pursuit of happiness.
    If rap annoys, you’d probably really suck at it so do what makes you happy.

    When Im angry or miserable Im write with dissonance.
    Since Im always happy I just go to Fox, CNN, or talk to my x wife so I can get pissed off enough for minor 2nds and major 7 9 flat 10ths.
     
    Stillneon likes this.
  14. Parsifal666

    Parsifal666 I don't even own a DAW, I'm just a troll.

    3,839
    3,544
    Sep 7, 2015
    E. YeeHaw, Indiana
    There's a piece by John Cage that trumps even that for anti-music. That doesn't mean all of their repertoire is like that, in fact they're two of the best music composers of the last century.

    I think what was originally meant is that Rap is basically like Beat poetry with a real beat. Anything resembling music is typically sampled and/or so rudimentary as to rightfully be judged incidental. Just like Wagner attempted to prove that music had to be subservient to drama in his opera, thus in Rap music is secondary to the lyrics.

    I have nothing against Rap/Hip Hop, though both it and Country Western music are the only two genres of music I never willingly listen to (and, to be honest, generally don't care for).

    I think music (and in the case of most Pop, novelty) is there to be enjoyed by everyone, for any reason. Hell, I still listen to AC/DC and KISS now and again, and there's no great shakes going on there musically either (yeah, I know it could be argued they're relatively more musically involved than R/HH, but neither band nor R/HH move far away from four-chord-maximum template set by...hell, I want to say Chuck Berry, but I imagine folk/pop music goes back much farther with the template). Even the bands that proclaim progressivity in the Pop arena are most often just musicians showing off for other musicians.

    Listen and let listen. Just don't try and convince me any of it is as relevant as Beethoven (but that's just me).
     
    Last edited: May 23, 2019
  15. Jerry Growl

    Jerry Growl Composing Music in the Plastic Dark Ages

    135
    112
    Jul 4, 2017
    Belgium
    Stormzy should replace Mozart in UK music classrooms, study says
    ...
    Well there's all kind of studies these days. A long while back studies said it's would be a healthy thing for people to drink radio-active water. Took some time, but people finally concluded it wasn't.

    [​IMG]

    Later on people started driving on leaded fuel. Studies were ordered by corporations to deny health issues https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2014/04/cosmos-neil-tyson-lead-industry-science-denial/

    So when studies say "Stormzy should replace Mozart ", for me it tells much about the study itself.
    I don't think this study has a purely educational objective. I think it's just another market strategy.
    But of course it will take time for people to realize the error when falling for it.

    Did you know there's studies that prove listening to Mozart makes you smarter? ... As mentioned before, there's all kind of studies...
     
    Last edited: May 23, 2019
    ptram and KallumS like this.
  16. toomanynotes

    toomanynotes Active Member

    261
    47
    Jul 8, 2012
    If this is what is required, then why does it particularly need to be a certified music qualification? Everybody that listens to that stuff knows it inside out, so what is the point? Another disgusting dumbing down of society. Brings nothing new to the table. That’s what I think.
     
    ptram and Parsifal666 like this.
  17. toomanynotes

    toomanynotes Active Member

    261
    47
    Jul 8, 2012
    Trust me, most learners will take the course just to listen to the music.
    The amount of times I’ve heard kids beg for this type of music to be played in a classroom just so they can nod, singalong to it..waste time..and it’s ‘always’ the disprutive types, disaffected types.
     
  18. OP
    OP
    KallumS

    KallumS Active Member

    277
    333
    Jul 26, 2018
    Camden, London
    I went to a Steve Reich thing at the weekend, unfortunately I'm one of those that just doesn't get it :blush: couldn't stay for the whole thing. They also played Terry Riley in C, I feel like I have a long way to go before I become part of that listenership. Maybe I'm just uncultured!
     
  19. toomanynotes

    toomanynotes Active Member

    261
    47
    Jul 8, 2012
    Agreed...it’s in a bad state. If kids don’t want to learn, they are not going to change for music. How about introducing social apps on mobile phones, that would do it! Leave music alone.
     
    ptram likes this.
  20. toomanynotes

    toomanynotes Active Member

    261
    47
    Jul 8, 2012
    No you’re not. It can be dire sometimes.
     

Share This Page