Show me your d...esk

Discussion in 'GEAR Talk Forum' started by Lupez, May 30, 2018.

  1. Lupez

    Lupez Member

    87
    8
    Aug 1, 2012
    Verona
    Guys,
    sorry for the idiotic title but I need a suggestion on how to tuck a weighted keyboard controller under my...desk.

    Problem is, now my desk is at the right height for mixing / editing / surfing duties, but it leaves less than 10cm of space to tuck a keyboard before it hits my legs.

    Yes I could raise the desk a bit higher but I fear it would be uncomfortable for prolonged work.
    Alternatively I could look for a very shallow keyboard controller, but is there anything below 10cm on the market?

    Suggestions? thank you very much...
     
    steveo42 likes this.
  2. Gerhard Westphalen

    Gerhard Westphalen Scoring Mixer

    I got the Nektar LX88 specifically for that reason but the touch sensitivity is awful. Keyboards with the Fatar keybeds are the only real decent option unless you really want to dissect another keyboard.
     
    hozierschurch and Lupez like this.
  3. Alex Fraser

    Alex Fraser Senior Member

    928
    1,206
    Jun 21, 2017
    Welcome to the vortex, where we continually try (and fail) to get a comfortable working environment.

    The M-Audio 88 is the cheap solution, but you'll sacrifice feel and playability for ergonomic gain. I use one and don't really like it.

    Another idea would be to keep your existing keyboard, but place it behind your computer keys and mice. If it's too high on the desktop, you could "sink" it down by cutting a giant hole in your desk(!) and placing a stand underneath.

    <rant>I think the perfect solution would invoice bending the laws of physics. Currently, my keyboard is tucked under the desk, but I *hate* stretching over it to get to the mouse. On the other hand, placing it on the desktop means I have to stretch over the mac keys to play. Basically, I can't be satisfied either way. </rant>

    It's a process. Good luck!
     
    Kevin Fortin, brek and Lupez like this.
  4. Pablocrespo

    Pablocrespo Active Member

    If you could squeeze one more centimeter, I have taken the keybed of a yamaha digital piano and installed it in my desk, I think it is 11 cm tall.

    If you buy a doepfer, it could be even less.
     
    Lupez likes this.
  5. Saxer

    Saxer Senior Member

    3,724
    3,754
    Mar 30, 2008
    Frankfurt/Germany
    I have a Studiologic SL88 "flush mounted" on my desk. The work disk has a cut out at the front and the keyboard is simply fixed with three door hinges normally used for a yard gate.


    DeskTop-.jpg
    DeskSide-.jpg
    DeskBottom-.jpg
     
    Last edited: May 30, 2018
  6. jtnyc

    jtnyc Senior Member

    984
    589
    Mar 5, 2013
    This is a dilemma for me as well. I've been using this Studio RTA for years. I want to upgrade, but I can't find anything that will allow me to put my midi controller underneath without the main workspace being too high. I really like the Output desk, but it's 30.25 inches to the desktop (to high) and my knees will just fit under the controller with little room to spare. I have some back issues and it's imperative that I sit with my feet flat on the floor and have my knees at a right angle. That put's a 30 inch height of a desktop way to high... I've given up for now. My desktop is 26.5 inchs high. The controller is not in the ideal position here. It's a little high and a little far, but if I raise my chair a bit and pull it in close, it's not too bad.

    IMG_3184.jpg
     
    Last edited: May 30, 2018
    Lupez likes this.
  7. miket

    miket Senior Member

    978
    1,098
    May 17, 2016
    New York
    I went over, rather than under. My keyboard sits on my desk, right at the front, and I have an Ikea-hack "second level" (a shelf on four cabinet legs) behind it which my computer, mouse, etc. sit on. Everything is within reach, and there's plenty of room under the desk.

    The keyboard isn't quite as low as one might want it, but this'll have to do until I can get some excellent chillbot-grade desk.

    I can't take a picture at the moment, but I'll try to remember for later, not that it's such a groundbreaking or pretty setup.
     
    Lupez likes this.
  8. chillbot

    chillbot Forum Bot

    2,125
    3,978
    Feb 6, 2014
    La Canada Flintridge, CA
    I was just thinking what this place really needed was more desk threads.
     
  9. nilblo

    nilblo New Member

    28
    19
    Jul 2, 2017
    Hi, this is my setup. The chair , Capisco Hag, is the first one ever to allieveate my back-& neckproblems..
    I already had an electrically height adjustable column on which I put an IKEA massive beech tabletop named "Gerton" plus I put casterwheels on the foot, rated for the weight of course. Size of the tabletop = 75x155cm (29,5"x61")
    The monitor arm is an Ergotron HX to take the load of a Dell Canvas 27" pen&touch-screen.
    For keyswitches I use a Komplete Kontrol S25 keyboard. For playing, a Fatar Studio Logic 88 that sits on an IKEA "Hemnes" desk with 2 drawers. The desk is retrofitted with casterwheels with brakes.
    I write the notesymbols directly on the screen in Notion 6 and it is working flawlessly for me. I have N.I. Symphony Series and LASS first chairs but I rarely use them. My favourite library is Xsample Complete Library and that is all I need. Hans Josef Winkler@xsample has prepared rule sets for Notion. The sound of this library is very realistic and is really driving my inspiration. I have no need for a sequencer as I do not deliver anything but scores.
    Workstation.jpg
     
    Last edited: Jun 1, 2018
    Toby Alexander, NoamL, Lupez and 2 others like this.
  10. Josh Richman

    Josh Richman Active Member

    240
    126
    Feb 25, 2017
  11. nilblo

    nilblo New Member

    28
    19
    Jul 2, 2017
    Bad hair day today.. no - I always draw in Sketchup what I intend to build. I´m telling myself there will be less error that way. (You wish..)
     
    Josh Richman likes this.
  12. Alex Fraser

    Alex Fraser Senior Member

    928
    1,206
    Jun 21, 2017
    From now on, all desk pics must be submitted as slightly whimsical sketchup images. Love it.
     
    Josh Richman likes this.
  13. OP
    OP
    Lupez

    Lupez Member

    87
    8
    Aug 1, 2012
    Verona
    Thanks guys.
    I use a custom copy of a Sterling Modular desk, my setup has an SSL Nucleus in front of me plus some hardware on the side pods. It really is a mix-master setup so the only place available is beneath the top. I must assume no keyboard is less than 10 cm so I guess the only options are a modification of the desk to make it slimmer or placing the keyboard sideways. But the second option would force me to duplicate audio and video just for playing on the keyboard...ugh.

    IMG_0504[1].JPG
     
  14. nilblo

    nilblo New Member

    28
    19
    Jul 2, 2017
    @Lupez
    The chair I was referring to - Capisco Hag - comes with normal or extra high column. I recommend the high one.
    The "saddle"-shape of the seat makes it easy to sit on even in elevated position, your feet should rest completely on the floor an from pelvis to knee, there can be a significant difference in height above the floor, like how you sit on a horse. That way chances are that you won´t hit your knees in an under-the-table-mounted-on-extensions keyboard. You will have to raise the table surface the corresponding height of the keyboard of course. I often sit by an old architect table (drawing in Sketchup of course..) that is 98cm/38,5" height. Under the table top there is a drawer sitting quite low and I don´t collide with it thanks to the sitting posture on this chair. Capisco Hag is expensive though..but it solved my various problems.
     
    Lupez likes this.
  15. Alex Fraser

    Alex Fraser Senior Member

    928
    1,206
    Jun 21, 2017
    That's a lovely desk but really thick. I'd imagine with a weighted controller underneath you'll practically be sitting on the floor.

    Thinking outside the box then..
    Perhaps something like this on the desktop for when you want to write? It's thin and light enough that you can put it out the way when not required. You might even have space for the mac keys to remain on the desk too.

    I can't comment on the feel of the keys, but life is full of compromises. ;)
     
    Lupez likes this.
  16. Massimo

    Massimo Active Member

    408
    105
    Dec 10, 2006
    Ticino/Switzerland
    I used to have similar challenges as you Lupez and in the end I have opted for a motorizes desk where I can adjust its height to my liking, this solution will also give you the possibility to work standing up, which is great as too much sitting is not good and neither healthy. My two cents....Cheers, Max T.
     
    nilblo likes this.
  17. Mornats

    Mornats Senior Member

    808
    652
    Feb 21, 2016
    Bristol, UK
    That's very similar to mine in terms of layout. My mouse stretches over to the midi keyboard desk and I have a second computer (typing) keyboard under the S61. I can easily switch from my composing position to my editing position and it works well. It was born out of lack of space but I really like it now.

    IMG_20170815_191045__01.jpg
     
  18. Grizzlymv

    Grizzlymv Active Member

    433
    240
    Apr 12, 2016
    Canada
    Well, ask yourself the question where you work the most? On the midi keyboard, or on the computer keyboard/mouse? I asked myself the same question when I built my desk and I ended up preferring to have my midi keyboard under my desk right on my legs, and my computer keyboard/mouse and extra controllers on the top. I also use an iPad with touch osc just in front of my midi keyboard so I don't use much the PC keyboard/mouse.
     

    Attached Files:

    Lupez likes this.
  19. robgb

    robgb I was young once

    2,664
    2,667
    Apr 6, 2016
    Not mine, but a good idea:

     
  20. mc_deli

    mc_deli n trepreneur

    2,262
    1,048
    Feb 22, 2015
    Has anyone done a motorized desk with a slide out for PC keyboard or midi keyboard...?
     

Share This Page