What's new

Recommended workflow for creating notation from recorded MIDI performance

dsblais

Active Member
Hello. I am trying to improve my workflow for creating music notation that starts from noodling on the keyboard. Currently, once I've worked out a basic theme using a VI, I like to record the MIDI of a live performance in Cubase or Logic. To try to massage it into notation, I'll switch over to score editor and the result often means a struggle with latency and over-precision (quantization notwithstanding).

I'm interested in hearing how others approach this and what works for them. Thanks.
 
There is no perfect solution, yet.

To minimize frustration I try to limit the trip to one-way, preferably MIDI to notation. I would dearly LOVE to be able to move from notation to MIDI, and when I want to do that I end up playing the parts in - it works, it is a little bit time consuming, but the results are far better than any computer can do today.

When I do migrate from MIDI to notation (I use Finale) I just quantize the snot out of the MIDI tracks, then take a quick look at the PRV and maybe to a couple minor tweaks, and then I import. And then I edit.

The more I quantize the less I edit, and for a lot of projects the number of errors in low. Lower than you'd expect. Sometimes I will quantize sections, so if I have a section that is all half notes I can safely quantize at quarter note level, and if I need to quantize 16th note triplets I handle that separately.

Hope that makes sense.
 
From midi to notation I get better results exporting MusicXML from the DAW (using Logic and Dorico). That reduces the editing time a lot. Probably because Logic already interprets midi to notation very good and the interpreted results are exported via MusicXML.
I also like the way of playing a piano sketch track in Logic separated into musical functions (like comping chords, bass, melody). Not more than 3 or four staves and just (e-)piano. I import this sketch into Dorico and orchestrate from there.
 
Top Bottom