Most Disappointing Library Purchase?

Discussion in 'SAMPLE Talk' started by tsk, Feb 9, 2018.

  1. Casiquire

    Casiquire Senior Member

    1,731
    946
    May 7, 2013
    Interesting, i disagree. The only downsides are the dryness and sometimes tone but CH handles both of those better. In fact by virtue of relying more fully on actual samples rather than modeling often the tone is already better with CH. I do think there's a slight sacrifice of fluidity but the trade off is there's some built in expression if i want it.

    I mean this less to imply that you're wrong and more to explain my own experience, understanding that disagreement on matters of taste is totally normal!
     
  2. Parsifal666

    Parsifal666 I don't even own a DAW, I'm just a troll.

    3,846
    3,552
    Sep 7, 2015
    E. YeeHaw, Indiana
    The Hein instruments can take some EQ and reverb to sound great, and it can take some patience to apply such. Anyone whom gets really interested in preparing their music either for yourself and/or others stands a ton to gain by gaining even minor engineering chops.
     
    SoNowWhat? likes this.
  3. quantum7

    quantum7 I'm 50 now....it's all over!

    There are plenty of subpar libraries, but I honestly believe if you really know what you are doing, you can coax a great performance out of nearly any library.....it's just a bit more work and frustration, but it can be done! Some of my best work over the years was using very basic libraries. Sometimes working with material that is limited brings out the best in a creative mind. I often have found that libraries that can do just about anything can somewhat cripple my creativity....strange by true! I will NEVER let a limited library stop me from using it to its full potential...and sometimes even surpassing it with a bit of imagination...and even a bit of luck. I would rather open Melodyne and fix a performance with a limited library, rather than have to spend hundreds of dollars more in chasing the forever elusive "all perfect" library. :2thumbs:
     
    Last edited: Apr 2, 2019
  4. Casiquire

    Casiquire Senior Member

    1,731
    946
    May 7, 2013
    I never meant to indicate otherwise
     
    Parsifal666 likes this.
  5. Hasici

    Hasici New Member

    35
    56
    Apr 4, 2019
    8dio are masters at creating demos that don't translate with the same enthusiasm to the actual instrument. Practically any 8dio library I bought was a waste.
     
  6. WaveRider

    WaveRider Member

    131
    79
    Mar 17, 2019
    Couldn't agree more... especially the pianos.
     
    Casiquire, kleotessard and whiskers like this.
  7. sIR dORT

    sIR dORT Member

    149
    79
    Oct 26, 2018
    Yes. Had that with Synphony - decent library, but not nearly as useable as the demos made it out to be.
     
    kleotessard and whiskers like this.
  8. Robert_G

    Robert_G It really is just an expensive hobby for me

    287
    188
    Feb 6, 2019
    Whats his name Troels could bang 2 pieces of framing lumber together, sample it, and make a convincing demo out of it.
     
  9. Dex

    Dex Member

    94
    50
    Nov 21, 2017
    What? Why not? Is there not a viable cc remapping you could do?
     
  10. Random Guy

    Random Guy New Member

    30
    30
    Oct 23, 2018
    You're right. I definitely believe 8Dio is a company with very loose ethics. I was going to write a long post sometime in the future, but I'll just chime in now.

    Their libraries are substandard at best. A lot of recycled garbage which I believe is then fed to developers in India, and then churned out with a fancy cover.

    I have counted no less than four products I bought of theirs which are grossly out of tune with the tune key switch feature. We're talking around two semitones. Off the top of my head, these are some of the vocal libraries, Hybrid Tools - Dark Prophecy, The New Ambient Guitar, and many more.

    To be frank, they just sound crap. And to top it off, my latest discovery is that 66 Basses has no extended sustain like all other libraries. Their version of sustain lasts around 6 seconds, then drops out. The library is completely useless to me.

    I have contacted 8Dio numerous times about these issues and more, only to be fobbed off and treated with indifference. They promise to fix the problem, but they have no intention to.

    Another issue is their Christmas sale bonanza, which is another way of schilling out their crapware. I fell for the trap and bought some of their libraries after being rewarded with a free one. It turns out that the last purchase did not reward me with the free library that I was only interested in. So, I ended up spending money to buy something I never wanted.

    I contacted 8Dio about this, and they said it was a 'glitch' in the system. I just love those excuses.

    And don't get me started on their 'competitions'. From what I've heard, they're also a time-wasting scam.

    In truth, 8Dio's pricing is overinflated. For a company to reduce up to 80% on a product during a sale is very telling. Even at these sale rates, the libraries are just not worth buying. Can you imagine Spitfire Audio and Orchestral Tools dropping a library price by 80%? It's unheard of. It only shows that customers are already paying way over the actual valued price with 8Dio.

    I truly believe that the fault lies with review sites who are given free copies to appraise, only to give disingenuous reviews, and not outline the fatal flaws in 8Dio's libraries. These review sites are terrified of giving negative reviews lest 8Dio and other companies fail to send new products in the future. I'm not mentioning any names.

    My advice is to stay away from 8Dio. If you read through these forums, they are certainly starting to get a reputation for shoddy workmanship and deceptive practices.
     
    Rasmus Hartvig and kleotessard like this.
  11. ProfoundSilence

    ProfoundSilence Active Member

    345
    340
    Dec 10, 2018
    Primary issue is that the pitch bend range is a maximum of 2, and the roli simply doesn't work well in this range. 12 or more pitch bend range makes it handle much better.

    an example(if my memory serves me) would be if you were to play an F, then an Ab - if it was a little flat - there is a chance it would try to read that as a G pitched up or something, and instead of a minor 3rd, I'd have a major 2nd. Hard to explain, but I didn't have this problem using the hein instruments, wivi, or even play engine.

    like I said, I'm not entirely sure why it behaved poorly - but the roli simply didn't work well at +2/-2, and samplemodeling has a max pitch bend range of +2/-2, scripted into it - and the developers have basically said it's not going to be fixed.
     
  12. Dex

    Dex Member

    94
    50
    Nov 21, 2017
    So the roli itself behaves poorly when you set it to +2/-2 pitchbend? I'm curious because Geoshred works fine with +2/-2 pitchbend vst's. (I don't have a roli or any of the samplemodeling stuff.)
     
  13. dexterjettser

    dexterjettser Member

    57
    54
    Sep 4, 2017
    Brooklyn
    Not exactly disappointing but if I had to do things over again when I invested in sample libraries I would have gone with someone besides spitfire. Spitfire makes amazing samples and I have no complaints about their quality but if I had to do things over again I’d go with orchestral tools. I like how comprehensive OT’s Berlin series is, certain things like them taking the time to sample different horn or flute players. Adds lots of realism when you can write for individual parts instead of blobs of sound. Berlin percussion has endless options for picking various drums. You feel like you have way more control of the orchestra. I feel I’d like Berlin strings because with smaller sections you have options for more realistic divisi. I like how everything is recorded in the same space. I like how you get all the mics in one place. I like how the legato is in the same patch as the rest of the articulations. I’m sure like any other library there would be quirks to work around but what I think really matters is just knowing your individual needs and how you work and then making a purchase. How patches are set up is a small thing but it really has altered how I’ve set up my entire template. Not a huge deal tbh. Also I’m a big fan of how the cinematic studio series is layed out-there’s something to be said for consistent interfaces that are easy to use. Spitfire interfaces are fine, useable but nothing special.
     
  14. ProfoundSilence

    ProfoundSilence Active Member

    345
    340
    Dec 10, 2018
    biggest issue with OT is the massive requirements to get full use out of them. ofcourse you could always set up a sketching template using 1 mic and 1 instrument per family, but don't beat yourself up - because if you don't have the rig to use OT in a way that fit your work flow - then you'd be having different headaches.

    but yes, it gripes me when you record for instance solo flute - then flute a2... JUST RECORD THE TWO SEPERATE FLUTES lol. Although sometimes I wish I just used a really small template with less options, because all the options can certainly be paralyzing at times.
     
    dexterjettser likes this.
  15. dexterjettser

    dexterjettser Member

    57
    54
    Sep 4, 2017
    Brooklyn
    I know right?! Like if I want to combine the flutes I’ll do it myself! Also I’ll point out I’m not really one for doubling woodwinds a2 (two oboes on one part just makes me uncomfortable for example). Spitfire has great samples, very resource friendly. They get the job done. And countless pros use them and the mockups always sound amazing. You do have a point with limiting options. The less libraries you have the harder you have to work to get the sound you want. Eliminates decision fatigue. That’s how I am with plugins. I’m not a mix engineer so I don’t need 10 different compressors or EQs. Just have my workhorses that I know well and can get good results with. But then I see something shiny and the next thing I know I’m checking out on PayPal
     
    ProfoundSilence likes this.
  16. ProfoundSilence

    ProfoundSilence Active Member

    345
    340
    Dec 10, 2018
    well if you have the money, I personally wish I had more than 128 gb of ram using OT.

    the multi in capsule is very powerful, but eats up ram like it's going out of style.

    but that said, if you have the ram to mix mics AND you use multi's to blend articulations - you don't need EQ or plugins.
     
  17. chocobitz825

    chocobitz825 Active Member

    493
    433
    Aug 7, 2018
    Lol, this thread proves you can't please everyone. Some love spitfire, some orchestral tools, some 8dio. I couldn’t get into CSSS at first, but then suffered through learning the fine details of the CC settings and then also gained an appreciation for spitfires versatility. Now orchestral tools are starting to show some lacking in versatility by comparison. Still, love 8dio and OT’s tone but 8dio in particular does have its odd quirks. I don’t think any of these makers are bad. We just have workflows and needs. We’ll probably never agree on what is best or worst because we all have different priorities.
     
  18. Random Guy

    Random Guy New Member

    30
    30
    Oct 23, 2018
    Releasing a product where the key tune is out by at least two semitones is a deal breaker, and a sign of a shoddy company. Even more when said company refuses to issue an update or an apology.
     
  19. ProfoundSilence

    ProfoundSilence Active Member

    345
    340
    Dec 10, 2018
    strange… there are some things I liked about SF library ui's - like the round robin stack feature, but I can't see where you feel like there is more versatility with SF's ui vs CSS... maybe I misunderstood you - and you enjoy the sheer amount of articulations in some of their symphonic series?

    I admit I kind of miss flautando, but being able to crossfade between 3 different kinds of bowing techniques in legato is unquestionably made SF obsolete to me. Although BS+ exp a and b isn't cheap - capsule has opened up a mountain of possibilities, even at it's steep resource cost. If there was another way to crossfade between other articulations - it would be awesome.
     
  20. ProfoundSilence

    ProfoundSilence Active Member

    345
    340
    Dec 10, 2018
    on the contrary, this is a thread specifically for airing grievances - and 8dio's quality control isn't exactly stellar. I know some talented people who use some 8dio patches because they are the only ones that can do what they do - but also aren't going to sugar coat them as being hit and miss.

    Nothing is sacred, and if someone bought something they were disappointed in - then it's perfectly fine for it end up in a thread titled "most disappointing library purchase". Maybe you confused this thread for the sub forum "SAMPLE Talk". Unless you're truly suggesting that criticizing libraries that people spend hundreds(and thousands) of dollars on should not be welcome on the internet, and users should just play Russian roulette and just buy libraries blindly hoping there aren't any serious faults that would prevent them from making a purchase.

    when Christmas sales were going on, there was a whole thread praising 8dio - so maybe you're overreacting on the negativity you're experiencing.
     
    EgM, Diablo3, kitekrazy and 1 other person like this.

Share This Page