Best Solo Cello?

Discussion in 'SAMPLE Talk' started by Daniel James, May 10, 2019.

  1. pderbidge

    pderbidge Senior Member

    803
    453
    Mar 23, 2014
    Utah
    For lyrical lines I've gotten great results from LASS FC Cello as well as Tina Guo.
    I went looking for a more versatile Cello and at the time Emotional Cello was on sale. The only problem is I think I'm the only person on this forum who thought the legato in the examples sounded too much like fake midi cellos of the past. Yes, it has a nice tone but there just seemed to be too much, to my ears, that gave it away as a fake cello. Nevertheless, there were so many people, whose musical works I admired, that love this cello so I decided to go for it. I usually never go against my own ears no matter how well loved a particular VI is by the community, but this time with so many great composers on this forum vouching for it, I went for it. After noodling with it, I was saddened by the fact that it sounded just like I heard it sound in the demos. The point is, if you like the sound of the demos then go for it, but if not, then don't because it does indeed behave the way it sounds in the demos. I did persevere though and opened it up again more recently and I believe I found a legato patch that I quite liked but I can't remember the name of the patch. There are also are a ton of other useful articulations in Emotional Cello that it will still get used. The Emotional Violin on the other hand sounds great to me and I was able to get the cross grade pricing on during the current Best Service sale.
    After some disappointment with Emotional Cello, I decided to pick up Tina Guo Vol 2 on sale and I prefer the legato in it over Emotional Cello, although I wish it had multiple legato options like you get with LASS FC. Also Vol 2 could use just a hair more vibrato to give it a bit more life therefore it's not going to have that same warmth that other Cello libraries do due to sounding a little bit unemotional at times that a little more vibrato would have remedied.
    So I'm still on the hunt and it will probably be Chris Hein Cello. Everything I've listened to sounds really nice and in traditional Chris Hein style it seems very flexible. I would also consider Audiomodelings Cello, however there is this certain buzzing in the sound that I don't like. Other than that it sounds really nice and is really flexible as well. If it weren't for the buzzing I hear I would have picked it up already given it's price. I'm still on the fence over Embertone's Blakus as well. I have the other two so I should complete my bundle some day. Honestly, if someone offered me my choice of the lot as a gift there's no doubt I think Chris Hein would be my first pick for Cello.

    One more to mention is the Cello in Macabre Solo Strings. It sounds really nice and you also get Violin and Viola with it. Only for legato lines but sounds like it excels at that. I don't own this one but I'm considering it.
     
    Last edited: May 11, 2019
    thov72, stfciu and ism like this.
  2. NekujaK

    NekujaK New Member

    48
    71
    Oct 19, 2018
    USA
  3. arcy

    arcy Member

    98
    52
    Jan 17, 2018
    Italy
  4. William Palmer

    William Palmer Member

    94
    55
    Aug 7, 2018
    London
    it's an instant-cello, hard not to love
     
    whiskers likes this.
  5. ism

    ism Senior Member

    1,138
    1,574
    Dec 14, 2016
    My theory is that there's a perceptual element to it. If you compare, say, Spitfire vs Chris Hein or Emotional, you have basically two extremes,

    Spitfire: "Uncompromising sonority with as much expressiveness as possible without compromising the sonority"

    CH: "Uncompromising expressiveness with as much sonority as possible without compromising the expressiveness"

    The spitfire approach naturally has a certain artifacts in the form of bumpiness when transitioning between dynamic layers and vibrato vs non vibrato, which impacts the expressiveness.

    Whereas the Chris Hein approach uses sophisticated techniques like phase alignment to avoid this bumpiness and maintain pristine expressiveness. Instead you get artifacts that impact the sound quality.


    And this is my experience listening to anything by CH and Emotional Cello - sublimely beautiful one minute, then suddenly a kind of "synthyness" in the sound quality coming from an underlying modelling technique. For me this just breaks the illusion, and is the only reason I haven't yet picked up these instruments. (Though there's still lots I love about them)

    I can certainly hear the artifacts of the underly sampling techniques in the spitfire instrument, but they just don't bother me in the same way. They don't seem break the emotional illusion of listening to a cello, even if I know perfectly well intellectually that I'm hearing a few unrealistic artifacts in a line. I also think that they wash out more easily in context.

    Many people seem to experience the exact opposite though. And I don't doubt their experience at all, which why I think there's something going on here at a fairly deep perceptual level.

    As, I think it was Dumbledore who said: "Of course it's happening in your head Harry, but that doesn't mean it's not a real cello".
     
    Last edited: May 12, 2019
    miket, cug, composerdk and 4 others like this.
  6. ChrisSiuMusic

    ChrisSiuMusic Senior Member

    My preference has always been Tina Guo Legato and V2, but then again I haven’t written music needing other styles of cello. For what it does, Tina’s libraries work very well.
     
    sourcefor likes this.
  7. stfciu

    stfciu Active Member

    172
    116
    Aug 13, 2017
    To be honest I am happy it is not only me that hear that things in emotional cello and I had exactly the same feelings.

    However as @pderbidge mentioned the emotional violin seems much better. I would really love to see update on the cello that would receive similar approach. Then it might be perfect.

    But I do agree how @ism describes it. For this teritory (expressiveness) I still think emotional cello does it best along maybe with chris hein which I don't own to confirm this.

    I don't regret my purchase anyway. I still think this is one of the best.

    It is interesting what have been said about cinematic studio solo strings though as they would be my next choice. Now I have to take a closer look on spitfire solo strings till my wishlist cart is still on ;)
     
    pderbidge and ism like this.
  8. Przemek K.

    Przemek K. Senior Member

    760
    288
    May 5, 2008
    I'd say there is no best but only whats best for a specific piece of music you are aiming for.
    You want beautyful slow emotional lines, get Cinesamples Tina Guo Cello legato, maybe Virharmonic Bohemian Cello, You want to go for faster yet expressive stuff with tons of articulations, go for Chris Hein Solo Cello (you get actually 4 different Cellos in one lib) or Emotional Cello from Harmonic Subtones. It really depends on the type of music aou write, but also what features you need to suit your workflow. And personal taste of course, which is..well a personal matter I guess.
     
    constaneum and TigerTheFrog like this.
  9. MichaelVakili

    MichaelVakili New Member

    30
    32
    May 2, 2019
    Besides the Tina Guo - Blakus Cello /Embertone /,Nocturne cello /Orchestral Tools/ and Emotional Cello /Best Service/ are all great cello libraries.
     
  10. VgsA

    VgsA Active Member

    269
    178
    May 23, 2014
    As with other cello threads, I'm leaving here my official demo for Emotional Cello, I honestly think I wouldn't be able to pull this one off with any other virtual cello. But definitely, different tracks demand different cellos, at least IMO.
     
    SoNowWhat?, RightOnTime, ism and 2 others like this.
  11. Pixelee

    Pixelee Active Member

    242
    85
    Apr 27, 2014
    Chris Hein and Virharmonic. Chris Hein has a lot of articulations, lots of possibilities. I quite like the British Cello tone.
     
  12. wst3

    wst3 my office these days

    3,888
    1,161
    Apr 2, 2010
    Pottstown, PA
    What Przemek said - it depends!

    I tend to start with either Tina Guo (either one) or Embertone Blakus Cello. But sometimes they are not exactly what I am looking for, so I'll turn to 8Dio, or VSL, or Spitfire, or sometimes (when I'm feeling especially masochistic) the Garritan Gofriller.

    And "what I am looking for" could be as much playability as sound or available articulations.

    I may be a little unsophisticated myself, but I do not find the lack of a proper cello (or anything) to be nearly as limiting as my own skills as a composer or user of virtual instruments.

    If I had an unlimited budget I'd probably own more, but really, I'm in pretty good shape these days.

    The problem, of course, is that it is impossible to audition all of them, so we are left to the mercy of user demos. I don't envy anyone just starting out!
     
  13. nas

    nas Active Member

    413
    167
    Dec 28, 2015
    Jordan / Toronto
    Another voter for Virharmonic. It has a gorgeous sound and I think they really hit on something with the bowing control. It's easy to play out of the box and very expressive but when you start to gain more facility and fluency with the forced key switches, you can get even more control and detail.
     
    jneebz, whiskers and ism like this.
  14. TigerTheFrog

    TigerTheFrog I'm supposed to be working now.

    1,264
    1,854
    Nov 18, 2016
    Brooklyn, NY
    Let me settle this once and for all with Brett Chen and Eddy Yang's TwoSet Violin video, "$1000 vs. $10,000,000 Violin." There are two things that come out of this video: first, a world-class musician like Benny Tseng can make any instrument sound good; and second, a world-class instrument can make any musician sound better.

    I realize this is not a completely scientific test, but I trust Brett and Eddy.



    So: Tina Guo has Gand & Bernadel Cello made in Paris in 1878. It costs a ton more $$$ than the other ones that were sampled for the other instruments, which as everybody knows, proves it is the best. To my untrained ears, the tone is yummily sonorous.

    So the winner is Tina Guo, probably by a few hundred thousand bucks!! :dancer:

    Also, as Brett and Eddy also show, some of you are better musicians than others, and could generate convincing and beautiful cello music with probably any cello VI, although more likely with Hein, because you really need to know your shit to manipulate all those freaking sliders.
     
    dflood and David Cuny like this.
  15. midiman

    midiman Active Member

    346
    288
    May 30, 2010
    Los Angeles
    1- Tina Guo Legato V1

    2- Virharmonic Bohemian Cello
     
    pderbidge and whiskers like this.
  16. ism

    ism Senior Member

    1,138
    1,574
    Dec 14, 2016
    Really superb expressiveness. And the thought of trying to get anywhere near this music space with anything other the EC or CH makes me shudder.
     
    SoNowWhat? and VgsA like this.
  17. VgsA

    VgsA Active Member

    269
    178
    May 23, 2014
    Thank you! TBH, I've never tried @Chris Hein 's cellos, so I wouldn't know, but based on previous experiences with the woodwinds (official demo below), I think they could be really inspiring too!

     
    chocobitz825 and ism like this.
  18. Trinity

    Trinity New Member

    5
    0
    Mar 27, 2019
    For sure Chris Hein is the one.:2thumbs:
     
  19. chocobitz825

    chocobitz825 Senior Member

    500
    437
    Aug 7, 2018
    For emotional cello, I wonder if perhaps some saturation or distortion and maybe some room emulation might change the overly smooth parts that end up sounding synth...I haven’t gone back into it in a while, but it definitely is one that provides the most expressive playing options, at the expense of a truly sampled instrument’s sound.
     
    pderbidge likes this.
  20. SoNowWhat?

    SoNowWhat? realised I can type here

    1,967
    1,585
    Jul 26, 2016
    HS's Emo Cello here.
    Thanks again Abel @VgsA
     
    VgsA likes this.

Share This Page