well my concerns are we are seeing suggestions for a set of attributes focused around orchestral libraries - and I dont see your comments addressing that.It shouldn't be "Orchestral only" - it should concern all samples. Orchestral just boosts the most variety, and the people here work mostly with those - so the talk is about that currently. So, for other (non-orchestral) sample libraries, the input is very welcome - because that also weighs in in the "proper middle of the road for everybody".
Apart from that - the backend (and current frontend) is not biased towards orchestral. It happens to have two Orchestral sample libraries in there - But I could very well throw an Orange Tree guitar in - it shoudl essentially work the same.
Do you have other concern that I'm not seeing/addressing here?
To be specific:
Instrument Details (Section sizes, Brands...)
-- what would this be if its not an orchestral Library?
-- a select-able list - that makes no sense for (say) a synth library
-- again if (say) I'm sampling some hand-crafted set of presets from my Moog and I'm DI-ing this into my Audio interface - then this makes no sense at all...
So to stop me being Jonny-negative any further perhaps we can re-name these:
Mic Positions - should really be "Capture System" (so you can say if you used 27 different mics in Air Studio -or if you just DI-ed it into your Lynx audio interface.
Articulations, might be Audio Variants - so if you have articulations you can list them or if say you've recorded every one of your Synth patches dry and thru some esoteric foot-pedal you can name these too.